Tab 02 · Evidence Collection · 5 to 18 October 2026 · Lead: Rocky Hill · Updated 9 Oct

Evidence Collection

A two week window to gather the material the project will be built on. This tab holds only NEW evidence and leads identified after the Project Plan was drafted; the foundation sources stay on the Initial Research tab untouched. Everything here is aimed at the specific evidence gaps named in Project Plan section 3.4. The quality screen, Objective Rule, coverage by objective, and priority gaps now live on the Assess and Organize tab.
ExpandGo beyond what the team already has. Find more sources: field experiments, standards, non Western data, DXC materials, case studies, and interviews.
AssessCheck each source for quality before it enters the base. Is it credible, current, relevant, and free of unexamined commercial interest?
OrganizeSort the evidence by project objective so it is clear which objectives are well supported and which still need more.
Map: Objective RuleThe rule every lead uses to tag a source to O1 to O5.

Expand: New Source Leads, Grouped by the Gap They Close

Project Plan section 3.4 named three evidence gaps: no consistent definition or measure of AI value, little evidence directly linking trust and change readiness to financial results, and an evidence base dominated by Western consultancy research. The groups below attack those gaps, plus two more needs that surfaced in scoping: governance benchmarks for the maturity model, and fresher failure data. Each card states why it earns a place now.

Gap 1 · Causal, measured evidence of AI value (not self reported surveys)

The strongest weakness in the current base: almost every value number is a self reported executive survey. These are randomized and natural field experiments with measured outputs, the highest quality evidence available on what AI actually does to productivity and quality.

Organization Science · 2026

Navigating the Jagged Technological Frontier

Peer Reviewed Journal

Dell'Acqua, McFowland, Mollick, Lifshitz, Kellogg and colleagues ran a field experiment with 758 BCG consultants. Inside AI's capability frontier, consultants with AI finished more tasks, faster, at measurably higher quality; outside the frontier, AI use made results worse. Originally the famous 2023 HBS working paper, now published in a top peer reviewed journal.

Why now: Closes the measurement gap with experimental data, and the jagged frontier concept gives Q2 (What AI Is Not) an academic backbone to pair with Gartner's agent washing.
Open Source
The Quarterly Journal of Economics · 2025

Generative AI at Work

Peer Reviewed Journal

Brynjolfsson, Li, and Raymond studied 5,172 customer support agents in a staggered real world rollout. AI assistance raised productivity 15% on average, with the largest gains for less experienced workers, improved customer sentiment, and improved employee retention.

Why now: The retention finding is the closest thing in the literature to a measured link between worker experience and business results, exactly the trust to outcomes connection gap 2 of the plan flags as missing.
Open Source
Science · 2023

Experimental Evidence on the Productivity Effects of Generative AI

Peer Reviewed Journal

Noy and Zhang's randomized experiment on professional writing tasks: ChatGPT cut time taken by about 40% while raising output quality, and it compressed the gap between weaker and stronger performers rather than widening it.

Why now: A second independent experimental result confirming where value lands (task productivity) and for whom (lower skilled workers most), published in one of the two most prestigious journals in science.
Open Source
Harvard Business School · 2025

The Cybernetic Teammate

Academic Working Paper

Dell'Acqua, Sadun, Lakhani and colleagues' follow up field experiment at Procter and Gamble: individuals working with AI matched the performance of two person teams without AI, and AI use broke down the usual silo between commercial and technical staff.

Why now: Moves the value question from individual productivity to team and operating model design, the exact layer where McKinsey says value is won or lost.
Open Source
Journal of Financial Economics · 2024 · Peer Reviewed

Artificial Intelligence, Firm Growth, and Product Innovation

Peer Reviewed Journal

Babina, Fedyk, He, and Hodson measure AI investment across US firms using resume based data and find that AI investing firms grow faster in sales, employment, and market value, with the growth driven by product innovation. Caution: the design is observational, and the gains show up in growth more than in measured productivity.

Why now: Closes the task to firm inference gap named in the O4 limitations. Peer reviewed, firm level evidence that AI investment converts into measured firm outcomes. Added 9 October to move O4 to Strong.
Open Source

Gap 2 · Linking trust, readiness, and change to outcomes

The plan concedes that trust evidence measures perception, not results. These sources get closer to the behavior and leadership side of the link.

McKinsey · Jan 2025

Superagency in the Workplace

Consultancy Research

Survey finding that employees are far more ready for AI than leaders believe: employees are already using AI for a large share of their work while leaders underestimate usage by roughly three times, and the biggest barrier to scaling is leadership, not employee resistance.

Why now: Flips the change management assumption in the plan. If resistance sits in the leadership layer, the maturity model's readiness dimension needs to measure leaders, not just the workforce.
Open Source
Microsoft WorkLab · Annual

Work Trend Index

Vendor Research

Microsoft and LinkedIn's annual study of tens of thousands of workers across 31 countries, tracking real usage telemetry alongside survey data: employee adoption running ahead of official programs, the rise of human agent teams, and the emergence of frontier firms.

Why now: One of the few large datasets pairing stated attitudes with actual usage behavior, which strengthens the behavioral adoption versus technical implementation question from the sponsor meeting.
Open Source

Gap 3 · Widening the lens beyond Western consultancy data

The plan names the Western, consultancy heavy skew as a limitation. These intergovernmental datasets cover most of the world with published methods and no product to sell.

International Monetary Fund

AI Preparedness Index

Intergovernmental Dataset

IMF index covering 174 economies across digital infrastructure, human capital and labor policies, innovation, and regulation. Shows advanced economies better positioned but more exposed to disruption, while emerging markets face a widening readiness gap.

Why now: Country level, method published, free of commercial interest. The backbone for the international comparison the RFS requires, beyond the adoption percentages already carded.
Open Source
OECD

OECD.AI Policy Observatory

Intergovernmental Observatory

Live database of national AI strategies, policies, and incidents across 70 plus jurisdictions, plus the OECD AI Principles that most national frameworks trace back to. Includes trend data on investment, skills, and regulation by country.

Why now: Lets the team evidence the regulatory divergence claims (Europe regulation first, North America innovation first, APAC scale first) with primary policy data instead of secondhand summaries.
Open Source

Gap 4 · Governance benchmarks the maturity model can anchor to

Dr. Kokkonen asked for a maturity model with stage gates. These three are the recognized external benchmarks a governance dimension can be graded against, which keeps the framework from being arbitrary.

NIST · United States

AI Risk Management Framework (AI RMF)

Government Framework

The US national framework for trustworthy AI: Govern, Map, Measure, Manage. Voluntary, widely adopted by enterprises as the de facto governance baseline, with a Generative AI profile added for GenAI specific risks.

Why now: A ready made, citable structure for the governance dimension of the diagnostic. An organization's distance from AI RMF practices is a measurable maturity gap.
Open Source
ISO/IEC · International

ISO/IEC 42001:2023 AI Management Systems

International Standard

The first certifiable international standard for AI management systems, covering governance, risk, lifecycle management, and continual improvement. Organizations can now be audited and certified against it.

Why now: Certification is a hard, binary stage gate, exactly the graded timeline artifact the sponsor asked for. Few maturity models in the consultancy literature anchor to it yet, which is a differentiation opportunity.
Open Source
European Commission

The EU AI Act: Regulatory Framework on AI

Regulation

The world's first comprehensive AI law, phasing in through 2026 and 2027 with risk tiered obligations and significant penalties. The reference point for Europe's regulation first posture and for compliance as a value protection activity.

Why now: Turns the international perspective from description into consequence: the same AI investment carries different compliance cost and risk by region, which belongs in the framework's regional factor.
Open Source

Gap 5 · Fresher failure and abandonment data

The initial base leans on the contested MIT 95% figure and Gartner's forward prediction. These add measured abandonment rates and systematically studied root causes.

RAND Corporation · 2024

The Root Causes of Failure for AI Projects

Policy Research Institute

RAND interviewed 65 experienced data scientists and engineers and synthesized five root causes of AI project failure, led by leaders misunderstanding or miscommunicating the problem to be solved, with inadequate data and infrastructure close behind. Technology shortcomings rank last.

Why now: Independent, non commercial confirmation of the organizational over technical thesis, insulating the Q4 argument from the consultancy bias critique in plan section 3.4.
Open Source
S&P Global Market Intelligence · Mar 2025

AI Abandonment Jumps from 17% to 42%

Analyst Research

S&P's survey of 1,000 plus enterprises across North America and Europe: the share of companies abandoning most of their AI initiatives jumped from 17% in 2024 to 42% in 2025, with an average 46% of proofs of concept scrapped before production. Cost, data privacy, and security cited as top causes.

Why now: A measured abandonment rate, not a prediction, and a dramatic one year trend line for the report's problem statement. Now cited from S&P's own Voice of the Enterprise research note, the primary source (updated 9 October).
Open Source
Gartner · July 2024

30% of GenAI Projects Abandoned After Proof of Concept

Analyst Research

The predecessor to the agentic prediction already carded: Gartner forecast at least 30% of generative AI projects would be abandoned after proof of concept by end of 2025, citing poor data quality, inadequate risk controls, escalating costs, and unclear business value.

Why now: Pairing the 2024 prediction with S&P's 2025 measured 42% shows the forecast was conservative, a clean before and after exhibit for the report.
Open Source
Primary source update (9 Oct): the Initial Research tab links the MIT NANDA findings through a Yahoo Finance summary. That tab is frozen, so cite the primary report the Project Plan already cites: The GenAI Divide: State of AI in Business 2025 (full report PDF). The primary entry has been added to the reference list on the Assess and Organize tab.
Figure check (9 Oct, verified): the Initial Research Q2 card says 39% received AI training while Project Plan 3.1 says 47%. Both figures are correct and come from the same Gillespie et al. (2025) study, measured on different populations. 39% is the share of ALL respondents in the 48,000 person global sample reporting some form of AI training or education. 47% is the share of the EMPLOYEE subsample who say they have received AI training, from the AI at work findings as stated in the University of Melbourne media release for the study. Cite 47% for claims about employees and 39% for claims about the general public, name the population either way, and confirm the page number in the full report PDF before the final submission.

Sources Cited in the Project Plan, Added to the Hub

Five sources the Project Plan cites that were not yet carded, closing priority gap 8. Two anchor the maturity model build for O5 and two are the method sources behind the plan's integrative review and thematic synthesis.

MIT CISR · 2024

Building Enterprise AI Maturity

Academic

Weill, Woerner, and Sebastian define four stages of enterprise AI maturity from research on 721 companies, with financial performance rising by stage. Caution: the evidence is correlational, not causal.

Why now: The published maturity model closest to what the team must build, and the first external comparison point for O5.
Open Source
Business & Information Systems Engineering · 2009

Developing Maturity Models for IT Management

Peer Reviewed Journal

Becker, Knackstedt, and Pöppelbuß set out a tested procedure model for building maturity models, including the design steps and evaluation criteria a defensible model must meet.

Why now: The method source for HOW to build the O5 maturity model, so the framework's construction can be cited, not just its content.
Open Source
Qualitative Research in Psychology · 2006

Using Thematic Analysis in Psychology

Peer Reviewed Journal

Braun and Clarke's standard reference for thematic analysis: the six phase process the team's thematic synthesis of qualitative evidence follows.

Why now: Method source for the analysis stage. Citing it makes the synthesis approach defensible to markers.
Open Source
Journal of Business Research · 2019

Literature Review as a Research Methodology

Peer Reviewed Journal

Snyder's overview and guidelines for literature reviews, including the integrative review design the plan's research approach is built on.

Why now: Method source anchoring the overall research design in a peer reviewed methodology.
Open Source
Microsoft AI Economy Institute · 2026

Global AI Adoption in 2025: A Widening Digital Divide

Vendor Research

Country level AI diffusion data: 64.0% of the working age population in the UAE and 60.9% in Singapore use AI, against 28.3% in the US, with the divide between high and low income economies widening.

Why now: Primary data behind the adoption outliers previously cited secondhand, and non Western coverage for the international lens on O2.
Open Source

Public Cases for the Four Stage Walk Through (O4 and O5)

Five shortlisted public cases that trace capability, adoption, outcome, and sustained value inside one organization, across industries, regions, success, failure, and reversal. Added 9 October to move O4 to Strong; the team picks three at the 14 October review, and Harvard entries for the chosen cases' articles get added then. Figures are company or media reported, so verify each against the linked source before citing.

Klarna · 2024 to 2025 · Fintech, Europe

Klarna: The Full Chain, Reversal Included

Public Case

The OpenAI built assistant launched in early 2024 handling two thirds of service chats, doing the work of about 700 agents with a projected $40 million profit improvement. By May 2025 the CEO was hiring human agents back on quality grounds while revenue per employee climbed toward $1 million. Capability, adoption, outcome, and a contested sustained value stage, all on the public record.

Why now: The strongest walk through candidate: every stage of the O4 chain is publicly documented, including the stage most cases hide.
Open Source
McDonald's and IBM · 2021 to 2024 · QSR, United States

McDonald's Drive Thru AI: Capability Without Outcome

Public Case

A roughly two year automated order taking test across more than 100 US drive thrus, ended in mid 2024 after widely shared accuracy failures. A clean case of task capability that never converted into an operating outcome, with the partnership wound down rather than scaled.

Why now: The failure anchor for the chain: adoption happened, the outcome stage did not, and the project was abandoned, matching the Gartner and S&P abandonment data at single company level.
Open Source
JPMorgan · 2024 to 2025 · Banking, United States

JPMorgan: Scaled, Sustained Enterprise Value

Public Case

LLM Suite rolled out to roughly 200,000 employees with publicly described use cases across advisors, operations, and engineering, backed by one of the largest technology budgets in banking. The success at scale candidate. Caution: value figures are company self reported at investor events, so verify current numbers before citing.

Why now: The sustained value anchor: one organization publicly operating AI at enterprise scale over multiple years rather than a pilot.
Open Source
IKEA (Ingka Group) · 2021 to 2026 · Retail, Europe

IKEA: Redeployment Instead of Replacement

Public Case

The Billie bot absorbed a large share of routine customer inquiries while 8,500 call center workers were retrained as interior design advisors, turning a cost center into a revenue stream. Adoption with workforce transition rather than headcount removal.

Why now: The workforce readiness case: the same automation, routed through retraining, produced a different outcome stage, feeding both O4 and the O2 stakeholder lens.
Open Source
Commonwealth Bank · 2025 · Banking, APAC

Commonwealth Bank: The Retracted Outcome Claim

Public Case

Australia's biggest bank announced 45 role cuts tied to its AI chatbot in 2025, then reversed the decision within weeks and called it a mistake after the union showed call volumes had not fallen as claimed. An outcome claim that failed public scrutiny.

Why now: Shows why the O4 chain separates claimed outcomes from measured ones, and adds the APAC region the evidence base lacks.
Open Source

Primary evidence the team can create

Expanding is not just finding documents. The team's own position gives it primary evidence no consultancy has, and Ducere explicitly invites surveys and personas as deliverables. Anything involving people goes through the plan's section 5 ethics and approval gate first.

Team Quantum · Primary Research

Practitioner Interview Program

Primary Evidence

Six to ten short semi structured interviews with leaders and practitioners across the team's networks, using the LinkedIn channel Dr. Kokkonen opened (she accepts all connection invites and encouraged cross group networking). Target a spread of industries, regions, and seniority, asking how they define AI value, where it leaked, and what they would measure differently.

Why now: Directly fills the trust to outcomes gap with firsthand accounts, and gives the report quotable, original material no other group will have. Requires the ethics and consent check in plan section 5 before any interview begins.
No external link. Owner and schedule to be set in the team's next working session.
Team Quantum · Primary Research

Stakeholder Perception Pulse Survey

Primary Evidence

A short anonymous survey built on the Melbourne and KPMG question structure, distributed through the team's combined networks across the six RFS stakeholder groups. Even 50 to 100 responses gives the perception heat map an original data layer to compare against the global benchmarks.

Why now: Ducere's deliverable guidance explicitly invites survey creation, analysis, and synthesis. Reusing validated question wording keeps it defensible. Ethics gate applies.
No external link. Draft instrument before 18 Oct so distribution can run during analysis.
Team Quantum · Desk Sweep

DXC Public Materials Sweep

Primary Evidence

A systematic pass through DXC's own public record: the full AdvisoryX study download, annual report and investor materials (how DXC describes AI demand to shareholders), newsroom releases, and Dr. Kokkonen's publication and speaking trail including her Trust in Government's use of AI talk.

Why now: Client data is off limits, but DXC's public voice is fair game and shows the sponsor's worldview in its own words, keeping the framework aligned without confirmation bias (test it against the independent sources).
Start at dxc.com/newsroom and dxc.com/investor-relations; log each find in the shared tracker.
Team Quantum · Internal

Cross Industry Mini Cases from the Team Itself

Primary Evidence

Five members spanning software sales (UK and global), digital marketing operations (London), government contracting operations (Hawaii), and construction and refrigeration services (Dallas). Each member writes a one page structured vignette of AI value creation or value loss observed in their own sector, using a common template.

Why now: Dr. Kokkonen called the team's neutrality and cross industry experience a strength. Structured vignettes convert that from a nice line in the intro into actual evidence, clearly labeled as practitioner observation.
No external link. Common template to be agreed before writing so the vignettes are comparable.